RP808
v2
Public Disclosure Authorized
GEF
Appraisal Report on Social Impact of
Shanghai Agricultural and Non-point Pollution Reduction Project by
GEF Donation
Public Disclosure Authorized
Public Disclosure Authorized
2009 08 26
Ecomomic, Legal and Social Consultancy Center
Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences
26/08/2009
Public Disclosure Authorized
1
1 ..................................................................................................................................... 4
1.1 ............................................................................ 4
1.2 GEF .................................................... 5
1.3 ................................................................................... 6
1.3.1 ................................................................................................ 6
1.3.2 ................................................................................................ 7
1.3.3 ................................................................................................ 7
1.4 ........................................................................................ 8
2. ....................................................................................... 9
2.1 ........................................................................................................................... 9
2.1.1 1 .................................................................................... 9
2.2 1 .......................................................................... 12
2.3 1 .............................................................................................. 13
2.3.1 ......... 13
2.3.2 ................. 13
2.3.3 ......................................... 13
2.4 ......................................................................................................................... 17
2.4.1 1 ......................................... 17
2.4.2 ......................... 19
2.5 1 ..................................................................................................... 20
2.5.1 ..................................................................................................................... 20
2.5.2 ..................................................................................................................... 21
3. ....................................................................... 23
3.1 .......................................................................................................... 23
3.2 .............................................................................................................. 24
3.3 ................................................................................................................. 25
3.3.1 .............................................................................. 25
3.3.2 ..................................................................................... 28
3.3.3 ................................................................................. 31
3.4 ...................................................................................................... 32
3.4.1 ............................................................................................................. 33
3.4.2 ............................................................................................................. 33
3.5 .......................................................................................................................... 33
3.6 ...................................................................................................................... 40
3.6.1 ...................................................................................................................... 40
3.6.2 ...................................................................................................................... 40
4. .................................................................... 42
4.1 .......................................................................................................................... 43
4.1.1 ................................................................................................. 43
2
4.1.2 ................................................................................. 43
4.2 ................................................................................................................. 44
4.2.1 ................................................................. 44
4.2.2 ............................................................................. 45
4.2.3 ............................................................................. 46
4.3 ...................................................................................................... 47
4.3.1 ..................................... 48
4.3.2 ............................. 50
4.4 ......................................................................................................................... 53
4.4.1 ............................................................. 54
4.4.2 ..................................................................... 54
4.4.3 ..................................... 54
4.4.4 ................................................................. 55
4.4.5 ................................................................. 55
4.4.6 ................................................................. 55
4.5 ...................................................................................................... 57
4.5.1 .................................................................................................. 57
4.5.2 .................................................................................................. 58
4.6 ...................................................................................................................... 59
4.6.1 ..................................................................................................................... 59
4.6.2 ..................................................................................................................... 61
1 1 .............................................. 62
2 2 .............................................. 65
3 3 .............................................. 67
3
1
1.1
Global Environment Facility "GEF" 2007 11
2008
6 24 GEF GEF
1:
1.1
;
1.2
;
1.3
2:
2.1 ,
2.2
3:
3
4
4
GEF
1.2 GEF
"
"2007
1858.08 GDP 12188.85
GDP 9000
2007 23623
2006 20668 14.3% 10222
2006 9213 10.95% 36.8
59%50-59%
40-50%30-40% 30%
5
2007 600
3.18 2.17 2006
1.47 2006 10222
32506
2007 7498
73.35% 754 7.38% 1970
19.27%
8845 3259
36.85% 476 5.38% 452 5.11%
571 6.46% 884 10% 857
9.69% 2097 23.71% 249 2.82%
1.3
1.3.1
1
2008.6.227.3
2GEF
2008.8.8
3
2008.7
4 2008.9
5
2008.8
6
7
6
8
7
8
9
102004~2020
11
""
12
13
14
2008
15
1.3.2
1.3.3
7
1.4
8
2.
2.1
760
40%
COD10.6 /BOD55.4 /TN
1.8 / TP 0.43 /
2.1.1 1
9
2.1.1.1
""
2.1.1.2
5km
28
500
""
38 3 15
10
2.1.1.3
30
2008 3
24 267 753
284 650.4
4000--8000
/2007 12000
11
2.2 1
16
2.2.1
4255m3 14 238
7659kWh 279 kWh 500KW
5000 9.3
2.2.2
1600
1.8 1.05 3
0.6 1.05
""
2.2.3
2187 10716
1022912 m³ 2802 m³
----
4000 10000
2kg 3kg
2920 4380
0.73 3200
2000 753
300 2kg 800
1
12
2.3 1
""
2.3.1
510 2 2006 6 6000
5300
4000 2~3
(2007)56
2.3.2
11 990
4
2.3.3
284 753
30 10.56%
2.3.3.1
13
3 66.6
68.5%18 60
74%
284
753
30
89
10.56%
11.82%
D01
89
D02
43
48.31%
D03
46
51.69%
D04 18
9
10.11%
D05 18 60
66
74.16%
D06 60
14
15.73%
D07
54
60.67%
D08
23
25.84%
D09
5
5.62%
D10
61
68.54%
D11 ()
5930
()
2.97
()
197.67
()
66.63
2.3.3.2
500 23.3%600
2000 70%2000 6.7%
10222
70% 30%
D14
1300
3
10.00%
2301400
2
6.67%
3401500
2
6.67%
4501600
14
5601700
7
23.33%
6701900
7
23.33%
79012000
7
23.33%
82001 5000
2
6.67%
95000
30
100.00%
2.3.3.3
59%50-59%40-50%30-40%
30% 63%
10% 70% 30%
10% 87% 13%
10% 80% 20%
10% 77% 23%
93%
D15
210%20%
4
13.33%
320%30%
5
16.67%
430%40%
6
20.00%
540%50%
4
13.33%
650%
11
36.67%
30
100.00%
D16
11%
4
13.33%
21%3%
4
13.33%
33%5%
45%10%
13
43.33%
510%20%
8
26.67%
620%
1
3.33%
30
100.00%
D17
15
10.5%
2
6.67%
20.5%1%
3
10.00%
31%2%
4
13.33%
42%5%
5
16.67%
55%10%
12
40.00%
610%
4
13.33%
30
100.00%
D18
11%
4
13.33%
21%3%
4
13.33%
33%5%
9
30.00%
45%10%
7
23.33%
510%20%
5
16.67%
620%
1
3.33%
30
100.00%
A11
0
2
6.67%
1
2
6.67%
2
1
3.33%
3
25
83.33%
30
100.00%
D19
0
3
10.00%
11%
11
36.67%
21%3%
0.00%
33%5%
2
6.67%
45%10%
7
23.33%
510%20%
3
10.00%
620%
4
13.33%
30
100.00%
2.3.3.4
""
16
2.4
2.4.1 1
2008 08
3
15
2008 08
21
7
2008 08
19
3
2008 08
20
3
10
17
1
2
18
2.4.2
93% 7%90%
73%
0 40% 50%80%
D20
1
28
93.33%
2
2
6.67%
3
30
100.00%
D21
1
27
90.00%
2
3
10.00%
3
4
30
100.00%
D22
1
22
73.33%
2
3
8
26.67%
30
100.00%
D23
1
2
12
40.00%
3
15
50.00%
4
3
10.00%
30
100.00%
19
D24
1
2
6.67%
2
25
83.33%
3
4
3
10.00%
30
100.00%
D25
10.05
12
40.00%
20.1
9
30.00%
30.15
6
20.00%
40.2
3
10.00%
30
100.00%
2.5 1
2.5.1
2.5.1.1
""
20
2.5.1.2
""
2.5.1.3
2.5.2
2.5.2.1
2.5.2.2
21
2010 12
""
GEF
""
22
3.
GEF 4
3.1
""
[2005]39
""
""
15
""
""
2010 1
GEF ""
23
GEF
3.2
10%-50%
3.1
1
2
3
4
24
667407.34m2
1
2
3.3
3.3.1
318
108.49 km2
3096.79ha33.8 km23052007
7632721155602488535
318320
6
25
93.66km2
3356.6ha1572ha425
2007199645295613435
8380
5
25557565215330929547
5013.23.3
3.2
1
267
735
133.5
205
2
160
510
200
17
3
267
888
1765
189
4
216
591
130
56
5
88
260
60
20
6
220
620
120
30
7
300
785
180
1447
8
119
336
19.04
9
166
500
100
57
10
298
890
150
80
11
339
1004
110.75
32
12
105
318
31.5
26
3.3
1
221
1046
145
133
2
181
842
118
76
3
235
436
165
82
4
118
559
98
79
5
334
975
527/2
22
6
424
846
238
12
7
755
2360
433
52
8
380
1126
250
26
9
315
934
527/2
16
10
129
423
100
3
12l°15 31°23
463.9
1800
4
2.14
34:66"" 20.6 "" 14.2 5.3
21.1
4.5%
1.73 1.06
27
170 316.3
3.3.2
4
(1)
-
2.7m 18m
8m 750m
240m
3460m20m
1200m2
DN225PVC-U
1.0mDN225PVC-U
(2)
--
8m 580m 560m
DN225 PVC-U
1.0m DN225 PVC-U
28
82 50m 50m
2500m2
(3)
---- 600m
790m 7 5-8m
1 8m
--
--
16720m
44m880m2
DN225 PVC-U
0.7m DN225
PVC-U
28920m39m
780m2
DN225 PVC-U
0.7m DN225
PVC-U
(4)
29
-
- 400m 550m 2.5-3m
15-18m
0.6km
5000m3/d1200 m3/d
DN225
PVC-U1.0m
DN225PVC-U
1.0m
A5 A30
12.6
""""
170041.8m2
63713.78m2 126463.03m2 84569.75m2
222618.98 m2
30
3.3.3
1
""
2
3
4
31
7
,
,,
3.4
5
800 30
32
3.4.1
3.4.2
3.5
33
1
2008 8 13
40
80 m2
34
1
2
2008 8 13
12
"
35
"
""
""
""
" GEF
"
""
""
""
36
2
3
2008 8 15
37
200 m2 250 60
2
3
38
4
2008 8 15
2
100
4
39
3.6
3.6.1
4
GEF
3.6.2
1
2
40
3GEF
4
41
4.
Global Environment Facility "GEF""
"
2009-2011
42
4.1
4.1.1
""
4.1.2
(1) 6
0.8 5.2
5
43
(2) 1
(3) 1.5
4.2
4.2.1
3 ,
2630
,
2400
3 7 3700
8730
44
4.2.2
6
28 9 138.6
2007
33.43 18.97%
8807 10.5%
2008 "
"
GDP38.5
15.2%2008
9494 7.8% 2008
586.05
58.04 3.2
2007
8 83
2007 GDP305.6
20.1% 9596 10.5%
51
12
45
1267
80 13 18 2007 69.7
0.3
2007 7485 10.3%
1315 1937
3400 6336
,, 6 , 378 ,
""
<2008
>
4.2.3
500600 /.()
46
80
3 2
2006
9213 2007
10000
2007
9800 8807 /
10
4.3
""
""
"
"
""
47
12
3 4
30
4.3.1
2008 8
48
4.1
/
2008 8
4
15
5
2008 8
13
8
5
2008 8
6
2
14
11
30
19
30 98
1
90
10
10
49
2
100
3
9010
95
4/
100
100
4.3.2
50
30 100
90 / 120 /
48 /
120 /
90 /
5
50
50
51
6
78
96
7
90
4 6
8
95
52
95
9
1
2
3
100
10"""
"
"""
"97
4.4
53
:
4.4.1
4.4.2
4.4.3
54
4.4.4
400/
250
/50100
/50100/
4.4.5
4.4.6
"""
"
55
4.2
4.2
2008 08
12
2
3
2008 08
13
5
8
90
2008 08 3
14
2
6
3
2008 08
15
4
5
56
1
4.5
4.5.1
""
3
10
57
48 /
GDP
3
4.5.2
58
,,,,,,,,
4.6
4.6.1
3
59
""
60
""
""
4.6.2
4000
""
61
1 1
GEF
/
"GEF "
A01 1 2
A02 1 26 1 6
31 2 1 42 3 2 53
A03 1 2
A04 11828 18 22838 28 33848
38 44855 48 55560 55 660
A05 1 2 3 4 5
A06 1 2 3 4
5 6 7
A07 1 2
A08
1/ 2 3 4// 5
6 7 8 9
A09 1/ 2 3
4/ 5 6 7
A10
1390 2391960 39612000
420013000 530014000 640015000
750016000 86001
A11 1 2 3
62
D01 D02 D03
D04 18 D05 18 60 D06 60
D07 D08 D09
D10 D11
D12
1 2 3
4 5 6
D13
D14
1300 2301400 3401500
4501600 5601700 6701900
79012000 82001 5000 95000
D15 110%210%20%320%30%
430%40%540%50% 650% 7
D16 11%21%3%33%5%
45%10%510%30% 620% 7
D17 10.5%20.5%1%31%2%
42%5%55%10% 610% 7
D18 11%21%3%33%5%
45%10%510%30% 620% 7
D19 11%21%3%33%5%
45%10%510%30% 620% 7
D20 123
D21
123 4
D22
123
63
D23
1234
D24
1 2 3 4 5
D25
10.05 20.1 30.15 40.2
50.25 60.3 7
D26
64
2 2
GEF
1
1 2
2
1 2
3
1 2 3 4
4
5:
1 2
3 4
6
1 2 3 4 5
7
1 2 3 4
8
1 2 3 4 5
9
1 2 3 4
10
11"GEF"
1 2 3
12
1 2 3 4
5 6
13
1 2
65
14
1 2 3
15?
1 2 3 4 5
16
1 2 3
4 5
17
1 2 3
4 5
18
10.05 20.1 30.15 40.2
50.25 60.3 7
19""
20,.
66
3 3
GEF
123
4
1
2
3
4
/
5
6
7
67
8
9
1
2
3
10
""""
68
4
GEF"
"
,
""
1)
,
2)
3)
4)
69
5)
70
71
1
1
2
2
1
21 2
1
2
3
72
4
5
6
1.
(
)
2.
3.
73
()
74
75