E2150
V1
Public Disclosure Authorized
*()
GEF SHANGHAI AGRICULTURAL AND NON-POINT
POLLUTION REDUCTION PROJECT
Public Disclosure Authorized
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT SUMMARY
DRAFT VERSION
Public Disclosure Authorized
PREPARED FOR SHANGHAI PROJCET MANAGEMENT OFFICE
Public Disclosure Authorized
BY EAST CHINA NORMAL UNIVERSITY (ECNU)
9 APRIL, 2009
GEF
i
GEF
2007
1800
6340.5km2
60 70
,
GEF
2007 11
GEF
20
08 6 24
GEF
GEF
1
GEF
2006
2010
20
05
15%
2006
2008
4.01
4.09
B
2
GEF
1993 6 21
(PMO)
(
1 C)
(
1 C)
(
1 B)
GEF
1
2006 7
2
2006 7
3
GEF
3
2007
11
4
2009 3
5
2008 7
6
2008 7
7
2009 2
8
2009 2
GEF
4
GEF
1
(1989 12 26 )
2
(2002 10 28 )
3
(2000 4 29 )
4
2008 2 28
5
1997 3 1
6
(1998 11 )
7
2004 12 29
8
2003 1 1
9
2005 2 28
10
2006 1 5
1
(2006.05)
2
(
)
(2004.12)
3
(2004.07)
4
(2008.06)
5
(2006.02)
6
(2005-2020)
7
2006-2008
(2006.01)
5
GEF
1
OP/BP4.01
2
OP4.09
3
OP/BP4.12
4
OP/BP4.36
5
OP/BP4.37
6
OP/BP7.50
7
OP/BP7.60
8
OP/BP4.11
9
OP/BP4.10
10
OP/BP4.04
1
(HJ/T2.1-93)
2
(HJ/T2.2-93)
3
(HJ/T2.3-93)
4
(HJ/T2.4-1995)
5
(HJ/T19-1997)
6
GEF
2-B
(GB3838-
2002)II
1-B 1-C
III
1-
A
V
V
2-
A
,
IV
1.1
1.1
(GB3838-2002) mg/L pH
No.
II
III
V
1
pH
69
69
69
2
DO
6
5
2
3
CODCr
15
20
40
4
BOD5
3
4
10
5
NH3-N
0.5
1.0
2.0
TP
0.1
0.2
0.4
6
( P )
(
0.025)
(
0.05)
(
0.2)
7
GEF
1-A 1-B 1-C 2-B
1
(GB3096-
2002)1
,
2-
A
2
2
1.2
1.2
(GB3096-2002)
Leq(A) dB
0
50 40 3 65 55
1
55 45 4 70 55
2
60 50
1-B 1-
C
2-
B
1-A 2-
A
1.3
GB3095-1996
1.3
GB3095-1996
mg/m3
TSP PM10 SO2
NO2
0.08 0.04 0.02 0.04
0.12 0.05 0.05 0.08
1
0.15 0.12
0.20 0.10 0.06 0.08
0.30 0.15 0.15 0.12
8
GEF
1
0.50 0.24
GB15618 1995
( 1.4)
1.4
mg/kg
100
mg/kg
350
mg/kg
250
GB15618 1995
mg/kg
300
mg/kg
0.60
mg/kg
30
mg/kg
1.0
(DB31/199-1997)
(GB18918 2002)
2-
B
(GB18918 2002)
B
1-B 1-C
III
1-
A
V
2-
A
IV
II
1.5
9
GEF
DB31/199 1997
1.6
(GB18918 20
02)
1.5
DB31/199 1997
mg/L
BOD5
20 30
CODcr 100
100
5
10
NH3-N
10 15
70 150
10 15
1.6
(GB18918 2002)
mg/L
A
B
BOD5
10 20 30 60
CODcr 50 60 100 120
1
3
5
15
NH3-N
5 8
8(15) 25(30) -
71
1
15 20 - -
10 20 30 50
1
3
5
20
3
0.5 1 3 5
10
GEF
1-A 1-B 1-
C
(GB5084-
92)
1
(GB5084-92)
1.7
(GB5084-92) (mg/L
pH )
BOD5
80
150
80
CODcr
200
300
150
SS
150
200
100
TP ( P )
5
10
10
pH 5.5 8.5 5.5 8.5 5.5 8.5
1-A 1-B
(G
B18596-2001)
2-B
GB14554-93
1-
C
GB14554-93
1.8
1.9
*%
70
11
GEF
*%
NH3-N (mg/m3)
1.0 1.5 2.0
H2S (mg/m3)
0.03 0.06 0.10
10 20 30
(GB12348-2008)
1-A 1-B 1-
C 2-B
1
1
2-
A
2
2
1.10
1.10
(GB12348-2008)
Leq(A) dB
0
50 40 3 65 55
1
55 45 4 70 55
2
60 50
1.11
12
GEF
1.11
mg/kg
(pH<6.5)
(pH 6.5)
( Cd
5
20
)
( Hg
5
15
)
( Pb
300 1000
)
( Cr
600 1000
)
GB4284 84
( As
75 75
)
( Cu
250 500
)
( Zn
500 1000
)
( Ni
100 200
)
HJ/T2.12.3-93 HJ/T2.4-
13
GEF
1995 HJ/T19-1997
1-A 1-B 1-
C
2-
B
I B
5
00m3/
[ 3
dB(A)]
300
2-A 2-
B
1-
A
1-B 1-
C
14
GEF
500m
100m
50m
1-B 1-C
GB3838-
2002
III
1-
A
GB3838-
2002
V
2-
A
GB3838-
2002
IV
2-
B
GB3838-
2002
II
1-B 1-C
«
»
GB3095-
1996
2-
B
«
»
GB3095-
15
GEF
1996
1-A 1-B 1-C 2-
B
(GB3096-
2002)
2-A
1-B 1-C
1-
A300m
2-
A
2-
B
1.12
1.12
1
100
1-A
2
100
3
2-A
15
4
34
10
5
82
10
6
167
10
2-B
7
289
10
8
76
10
9
10
($
16
GEF
EA
EA
17
GEF
18
GEF
2009 2011
GEF
2.1
:
19
GEF
*()
EA
(EMP)
GEF
4
2.2
20
GEF
,
:
$
1
21
GEF
2
5000
4000
3
,
4
2.1
2.1
1-A
1
2460m2
2
820 m2
3
740 m2
4
400m2
5
500m2
6
270t/d
22
GEF
7
17
8
3600.02
9
37.77 /t
10
14.27 /t
5
2.3
6
2.2.2
1-B
1
2
23
GEF
18750
0.6
1.05
7075
2130
4
000
3000
A
7075
2000
2000
300
2400
125
100
150
B
2130
900
1230
3000
3
2.2
2.2
1-B
1
18750m2
2
7075 m2
3
2130 m3
4
2500m2
5
1600m2
6
49.3t/d
24
GEF
7
9
8
644.90
4
A
B
5
2.6
25
GEF
2.2.3
1-
C
1
2
6900m2
10
.3
150m2
3m
4
m
4000
1
3
26
GEF
6900
90m×60m+50m×30m
5400
90m×6
0m
1500
50m×
30m
2550
1190
650
11000
1200
280
50
500
266
1993
150
600
4
2-3
1-C
1
6900 m2
2
2620 m2
3
2600 m3
4
94 kwh
5
2138m3/d
27
GEF
6
1801t/a
7
11093t/a
8
8
9
2072
10
106
/
11
20
5
A
2-
7
28
GEF
B
2.8
CSTR
UASB
C
2.9
29
GEF
CSTR
UASB
2.9
D
2.10
30
GEF
UASB
E
2
.11
2.11
F
2.12
2.12
31
GEF
$
1
2
667407.34
2.13
2.13
3
2-4
2-4
2-A
1
100260m3
32
GEF
2
2577m
3
48518m2
4
5
630.78
4
%
1
2
5
5
7
2
521m3/d
5
2.5
33
GEF
PG
1
155
918
117
2
260
641
82
3
440 1224
156
4
300 1077
137
5
105
239
47
6
4099
521
2-6
2-6
2-B
1
1139.66
2
521
m3/d
3
GB
18918-2002
B
2.14
2.14
34
GEF
GEF
32469.1
1
6.5
4995.3
6418.5
987.46
2155.6
,
331.63
2.7
:
2.7
$ 36,000,000 5,538,000
% 7,465,000 1,148,000
& 20,720,000 318,800
$ 7,947,000 1,223,000
% 13,609,000 2,094,000
85,741,000 13,190,900
35
GEF
1-A
1-B 1-
C
2-
A
2-
B
GEF
3-1
36
GEF
3.5m 4.5 m
3.87m
1145
1872 2115
15.7
39.6
-
8.5
1127.7mm
2170
3.2m/s
3.2
37
GEF
26 27km/km2
70
km
90 km
29300
m3/s
92600 m3/s
4620 m3/s,
9240 m3/a
38
GEF
80
108
km
8 17m
304
m3/s
3.28
m
2.5m
0.5 m 1.5 m.
20 30
m 240 250m
4
3.5
0.5 cm 10
cm
1.7 1.9
7
9
39
GEF
3.3
40
GEF
2007
7.79mg/L(I )
16.3
mg/L(III )
3.65 mg/L(III )
1.81
mg/L(V )
0.201 mg/L(
V )
3.71 mg/L( V )
2007
2006
2007
6.08mg/L(II )
18.5
mg/L(III )
3.64 mg/L(III )
1.60
mg/L(V )
0.187 mg/L(III )
4.19
mg/L
GB 3838-2002
II
2007
3.87mg/L(II )
18.0
mg/L(III )
3.04 mg/L(III )
1.47
mg/L(V )
0.263
41
GEF
mg/L(III )
4.18mg/L
GB 3838-2002 II
2007
4.98mg/L(IV )
15.6
mg/L(III )
4.22 mg/L(IV )
2.59
mg/L((
V ))
0.165 mg/L(III )
5.07mg/L
2007
2.84mg/L(V )
19.0
mg/L(III )
4.89 mg/L(IV )
3.59
mg/L((
V ))
0.338 mg/L(V )
5.62mg/L
2007
8.46mg/L(I )
7.12 mg/L(I )
1.06
mg/L(I )
0.53 mg/L(III )
0.203 mg/L(IV )
1.97mg/L
2007
2006
2001 2007
42
GEF
43
GEF
/
2007
(km2)
( )
(man /km2)
108.50 81961
755
93.66 70040
748
58.85 44580
758
45.54 30819
677
51 41000
804
18.61
42000
2257(
)
50.91 65000 1277(
)
3.36
,
17%
2006
7.3
1.25
8711
4
25
2006
32.4979
7.6848
12982
44
GEF
30
5
2006
37.25
94
3.3839
15.9%
12
5
2329.6
26%
21
2
38378
2004
4.939
2876.95
34
30
5
5
42000
2006
11.432
20.51
5.6
26.62%
4.71
14.23%
22
2
5091
45
GEF
1.8
1.05
7320
2500
800
2920
1100
4380
2-A
2-
B
46
GEF
1
z
z
z
$
%
500m
47
GEF
&
500m
z
z
z
z
z
z
$
48
GEF
%
A
34
4.1
4.2
1200
m2 560
m2
58m
1 m
49
GEF
4.1
4.2
B
50
GEF
82
50m
50 m
2500m2
70
m
69
m3/d
4.3
4.3
221
40
m3/d
297
30 m3/d
51
GEF
82
15
50m
50 m
2500
m2
27m
10 m
270
m2
4.4
4.4
B
C
52
GEF
D
167
20m
44
m
880
m2
4.5
53
GEF
174
30m
25m
750
m2
4-6
4.2
4.2
167
174
880
m2 750
m2
54
GEF
1m
1 m
E
289
20m
39
m
780
m2
55
GEF
4.5
19m
24m
456
m2
4.6
4.3
289
780
m2 456m2
56
GEF
10m
1 m
D
0.6km
5000m3/d
1200
m3/d
MSBR
57
GEF
GB18918-
2002
A
144
m3/d
300m
580
110L
78 m3/d
58
GEF
76
20m
20m
400m2
24m
20m
480m2
4.7
2
$
59
GEF
$
4.4
CSTR
UASB
USR
4
CSTR
TS8%-12%
15%
30%
50%
60
GEF
%
4.5
4.5
30% 40% 70%
3
32 % 40 45%
80% 5
30%
40%
70%
35-
40%
40-
45%
80%
%
1999
52
61
GEF
&
$
60
4.6
4.6
62
GEF
80%
70%
2400m2³/d
2100m3³/d
220
200
4.6
,
%
-
-
11.5MJ/m3
CO CO2 N2 H2 CH4 CmHn O2
H2S HCl
HCN SO2 NH3
63
GEF
$
-
-
-
1:2.5 1:4
%
64
GEF
Dece
ntralized Sanitation and Reuses,
DESAR
4.7
1
2
3
4
65
GEF
5
66
GEF
6
67
GEF
7
FILTER
68
GEF
69
GEF
70
GEF
8
71
GEF
9
72
GEF
73
GEF
10
74
GEF
75
GEF
11
-
12
MBR
12
-
4.8
76
GEF
4.8
15m2
0.1Wh/ m3,
11800
0.05 /m3,
0.15 / m3
4.8
77
GEF
$
$
5.1
5.1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
%
5.2
5.2
1
2
78
GEF
3
4
5
6
%
$
5.3
5.3
1
2
3
4
5
6
%
5.4
5.4
1
2
3
4
5
6
&
79
GEF
1600
1.8
1.05
5.5
5.5
kg/d
%
30 0.43 0.34
29.5 0.67 0.053
5.5
113.9
9.01
9.15
/ ·
5.13
/ ·
5.6
N
P
N
P
12448 1756 5363 1733
62.5%
2
a
20000
b
5000
c
12000
150
0
6000 ,
80
GEF
&
$
5.7
5.7
1
2
3
4
5
6
B
5.8
5.8
1
2
3
4
5
6
C
a
81
GEF
5.9
70.4
5.3
37.3
,
NJ KP
·
N 75
75
90
90
330
P 12
/
13
0
25
K 79
/
96
/
175
/ / / / /
b
5.10
5.11
T-N T-P T-K
%
%
%
%
(
) 3.9 0.7 0.9 30.4
0.1 0.03 0.3 86
1.25 0.23 0.48
69.24
82
GEF
CODcr
T-N
T-P
T-K
mg/L
mg/L
mg/L
mg/L
985 96 1043
500 3%
55.7
7.1
45.6
2513
3200
213hm2
67.2
9.6
33.7
1323
5.12
N P K
t/a 55.7 7.1 45.6 2513
t/a 67.2 9.6 33.7 1323
-
-
t/a
11.9 1190
11.5 2.5
%
-17 -26 26 90
$
$
5.13
5.13
1
2
83
GEF
3
4
5
6
7
%
5.14
5.14
1
2
3
%
$
5.15
5.15
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
%
5.16
84
GEF
5.16
1
2
3
4
$
$
TSP
z
z
z
z
z
z
85
GEF
.
z
$
z
z
GB12523-
90
22 00
6 00
.
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
86
GEF
z
z
z
%
%
TSP
z
z
z
z
z
z
.
87
GEF
z
z
GB12523-
90
22 00
6 00
z
z
z
z
%
z
z
z
88
GEF
z
&
&
TSP
z
z
z
z
z
z
.
z
89
GEF
&
z
z
GB12523-
90
22 00
6 00
.
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
90
GEF
z
z
z
z
$
$
TSP
z
z
z
z
91
GEF
z
.
z
z
z
z
GB12523-
90
22 00
6 00
.
z
z
z
$
z
z
92
GEF
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
%
%
TSP
z
z
z
z
%
93
GEF
z
z
z
z
GB12523-
90
22 00
6 00
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
94
GEF
$
$
z
70
dB(A)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
95
GEF
z
z
z
z
z
z
$
z
z
z
z
(GB5084-
92)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
%
96
GEF
%
z
70
dB(A)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
%
z
z
z
(GB5084-
92)
z
z
z
97
GEF
z
z
z
&
z
70
dB(A)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
&
98
GEF
z
z
z
z
(GB5084-
92)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
$
$
z
(DB31/199-
1997)
z
z
z
z
99
GEF
z
z
%
%
z
70
dB(A)
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
z
100
GEF
1-A 1-
C
101
GEF
2009 -
2011
GEF
$
102
GEF
CH4
1 CH4
25
CO2
,
55.98
SO2
1m3
1.12 2kg
SO20.018 0.032kg
0.0
13 0.024kg
SO256.43 100.3kg
40.76 7
5.24kg
98550
CODCr
2.7t/d
103
GEF
5700m3
14
252 ,
9720.5kWh
0.8
%
2007
104
GEF
&2'&U
CODCr
10000mg/L
18000
CODCr
180
6000
3000
700
1.05
3000
700
TN TP
6000
10500
9
100
105
GEF
&
2010
,
6.1
CODcr
6.1
CODcr
106
GEF
1
2920
0.03
87.6
2
4380
0.006
26.28
3
2000
0.035
70
4
800
0.028
22.4
5
10100
206.28
6.1
CODcr
206.28 /
21.0 / .
1801
11093t
780390m
1240000 kWh
t
1062000
26.8
/
$
107
GEF
%
108
GEF
5
5
5
521m3/d
2-
B
CODCr
55.15
t/a BOD5
30.43t/a SS
34.23t/a NH3-
N
3.23t/a TP
0.57t/a
N P
,
,
,
40
109
GEF
,
,
,
,
100%
100%
10%
100%
58%
40%
90%
1
123,850t/a
800t/a
190,165m3/a
2,000t/a
2
COD 1279t/a N P
3
4
28098t/a
4788000
110
GEF
111
GEF
2006 2
OP4.01
2008 10
http://www.envir.gov.cn/info/2008/20081023970.htm.
(http://www.envir.gov.cn/eia/2008/10232/) 2008
10 23
11 17
GEF
2734
105
31
112
GEF
54.84%
38.71%
20-35
9.68% 35-
50
80.65% >50
3.23%
87.1%
9.68%
58.06%
61.29%
58.06%
45.16%
48.39%
32.26%
61.29%
GEF
64.52
54.84%
25.81
2008 9 4
11 4
11 11
1-A 1-B 1-
C
58
63.79%
36.21%
20-35
22.41% 35-
50
39.66%
50
37.93%
32.75%
17.24%
29.31%
17.24%
6.70%
62.07
31.03
91.38%
60.34
31.03%
18.96%
18.96%
113
GEF
56.90%
37.93%
50.00%
10.34
%
36.21%
29.31%
91.38%
15.52%
17.24%
62.07%
84.48%
GEF
114
GEF
(03
,
,
,
z
5
8
/
z
BB
4
z
;
z
115
GEF
z
3
8730 ,
z
3
z
z
z
,
z
116
GEF
150
/
8000
1200
,
z
25
/
8000
200
z
8000
z
3
,
3
40
z
:
:
1100
z
,
z
117
GEF
z
25
z
80%
z
1
0
50
z
4
160
z
1
00
z
5000
2009 1
12
118
GEF
( )
N
N
(
)/
1
800
P
P
N
N
(
)/
2 /
3200
P
P
(
)/
40 /
15000
CODcr
CODcr
1000
TP
TP
CODcr
CODcr
2 /
4000
TP
TP
25kg/mu
(
)/
-
-
-
25kg/mu
(
)/
-
-
-
25200
2
3 2
1400
3
150kg/mu
(
)/
-
-
-
( )
(
)/
-
-
-
-
119
GEF
(
)/
-
-
-
-
(
)/
-
-
-
-
80%
(
)/
-
-
-
-
40%
(
)/
-
-
-
-
90%
(
)/
-
-
-
-
28
(
)/
-
-
-
25,200
840
(
)/
-
-
-
84,000
140
(
)/
-
-
-
8,400
112
(
)/
-
-
-
11,200
(
)/
-
-
-
-
(
)/
-
-
-
-
(
)/
-
-
-
-
(
)/
-
-
-
-
( )
N
N
(
)/
800
P
P
120
GEF
N
N
(
)/
2 /
3200
P
P
(
)/
40 /
15000
CODCr
CODcr
1000
TP
TP
CODCr
CODcr
2 /
4000
TP
TP
25kg/mu
(
)/
25kg/mu
(
)/
/
25200
150kg/mu
(
)/
2
3 2
1400
3
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
( )
80%
(
)/
40%
(
)/
90%
(
)/
30
(
)/
27000
121
GEF
900
(
)/
190000
150
(
)/
9000
120
(
)/
12000
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
( )
N
N
(
)/
800
P
P
N
(
)/
N
2 /
3200
P
P
(
)/
40 /
15000
COD
COD
cr
cr
1000
TP
TP
COD
COD
cr
cr
TP
TP
2 /
4000
25kg/mu
(
)/
25200
25kg/mu
(
)/
2
3 2
1400
3
122
GEF
150kg/mu
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
( )
80%
(
)/
40%
(
)/
90%
(
)/
52
(
)/
46800
1260
(
)/
126000
210
(
)/
12600
168
(
)/
16800
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
(
)/
123
GEF
(03
EMP
EMP
EMP
,
124
GEF
(03
(PMO)
,
(PIU),
,
PMO
EMP
PMO
EMP
9.1
9.1
$ 371,000 57,080
% 54,000 8,310
& 178,000 27,380
125
GEF
$ 88,000 13,540
% 115,000 17,690
806,000 124,000
9.2
9.3
9.2
(
)
(
)
$
15,200 15,200
%
15,400 /
&
12,400 /
$
17,900 15,100
%
14,600 /
75,500 30,300
9.3
(
)
(
)
(
)
$
11,800 /
/
%
11,800 11,800
/
&
11,050 11,050
/
$
8,000 / /
%
22900 22900 /
2,800
2,800
2,800
2,800
2,800
2,800
126
GEF
2,800
2,800
2,800
73,950 54,150 8,400
105,800
141,700
127
GEF
$
/
/
1 /
5600
30
,
/
SS,
BOD 1 /
18800
, CODcr,TP
10 00
6 00
/
Leq
1 /
4800
1-A
(2)
/
-
128
GEF
/
-
/
-
/
-
/
-
a
/
b
c
1-A
(3)
/
GB12348 90
I
/
Leq
2 /
1200
/
1 /
4000
129
GEF
300
/
-
-
-
-
/
2 /
1200
130
GEF
%
/
/
1 /
2800
;
30
,
SS,
B
/
OD
1 /
9400
, COD
cr,TP
10 00
6 00
/
Leq
1 /
2000
/
-
-
-
131
GEF
1-B
(2)
/
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
a.& b.
,
a
a.& b
CODcr, TP
/
b
2 /a
10800
BOD
c
c:1 /
c.TN,TP,
GB12348 90
/
Leq
2 /
2400
1-B
(3)
/
132
GEF
/
1 /
8000
500
/
-
-
-
-
/
2 /
1200
133
GEF
&
/
Ã
/
1 /
2800
30
,
SS,
BOD
/
1 /
6400
, CODcr,TP
10 00
6 00
/
Leq
1 /
2000
1-C
(2)
/
/
134
GEF
/
;
/
/
/
/
1-C
(3)
/
a.
, COD
cr,
a
a:2 /a
TP BOD
b
b:1 /
b.TN,TP,
GB12348 90
I
/
2
Leq
2 /
135
GEF
/
2
1
/
1
/
2
500
/
-
-
-
/
2 /
136
GEF
$
/
Ã
/
1 /
SS,
BOD
,
/
1 /
, CODcr,TP
/
Leq
1 /
/
Pb Cu Zn Cd Hg
2 /
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
2-A
(2)
137
GEF
/
/
-
/
-
/
138
GEF
%
Ã
/
2
30
,
2
/
/
-
2-B
(2)
/
10 00
6 00
/
2
Leq
1 /
139
GEF
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
,
/
-
-
-
/
-
-
-
2-B
(3)
/
SS,
BOD
/
, CODcr,TP
/
Leq
/
140
GEF
/
-
-
141
GEF
2010
2005
15%
123850 /
COD1279
,
,
4788000
28098
142
GEF
143